Best Sump Pump Reviews 2019 – Comparison

A sump pump is a device used to remove water accumulated in the water collecting sump basin, frequently found in the basement of houses. Sump pumps are mainly manufactured in the US with the best of water flow rate per hour and vertical float switch which is tested to approximately 1 million cycles. The Best Sump Pump has a rugged design which increases its durability and prevents corrosion of the material. It is certified by CSA for reliability and safety. The submersible reinforced dual- sealed thermoplastic construction increases the durability of the pump. The superior quality pump displays a constant-duty and split capacity motor for the best result. Let’s have a look at some of the best sump pump models being sold in the US.

Top 5 Sump Pumps 2019 Comparison Chart

  • Superior Pump 91250 1/4 HP
  • Item Weight - 7.6 Pounds
  • Product Dimensions (Inches) - 12 x 7 x 7
  • Flow Rate - 30 GPM
  • Voltage - 120 Volts
  • WAYNE CDU980E 3/4 HP
  • Item Weight - 12 Pounds
  • Product Dimensions (Inches) - 8 x 8 x 12
  • Flow Rate - 77 GPM
  • Voltage - 100 Volts
  • Superior Pump 92330 1/3 HP
  • Item Weight - 9.1 Pounds
  • Product Dimensions (Inches) - 7 x 7 x 13
  • Flow Rate - 27 GPM
  • Voltage - 100 Volts
  • Wayne VIP50 1/2 HP
  • Item Weight - 12 Pounds
  • Product Dimensions (Inches) - 6 x 6 x 10
  • Flow Rate - 41 GPM
  • Voltage - 100 Volts
  • Zoeller M53 1/3 Hp
  • Item Weight - 21 Pounds
  • Product Dimensions (Inches) - 7.8 x 10.5 x 10.5
  • Flow Rate - 43 GPM
  • Voltage - 115 Volts

Top 5 Best Sump Pump Reviews

Superior Pump 91250 1/4 HP Thermoplastic Submersible

The Superior Thermoplastic Pump is submersible and designed for steady and consistent domestic use. It comes with ¼ Horsepower technology and moves away 30 gallons water per minute from the swimming pools. The large 1-1.4 inches male iron pipe discharge thread is the best for high capacity pumping and the garden hose adapter makes it convenient to use. Read More

Best Features:

Rugged And Compact Design For Durability– Its constructed with durable thermoplastic which ensures that this submersible pump can be used in continuity without corroding.

Product Warranty- This pump is UL/CUL listed with CSA certification for dependability and safety. This Superior Submersible Utility Pump comes with one year of limited warranty.


  • Corrosion Resistance feature saves the pump from rust and decay
  • Comes at highly affordable price


  • The Pump has Oil leak problem which is unusable in hot water tub

WAYNE CDU980E Submersible Stainless Steel Sump Pump

WAYNE CDU980E is a fully submersible Sump pump made of harsh cast iron and stainless steel which prevents the pump from decaying and corrosion which increases its’ durability. Wayne Sump pump comes with 3/4 horsepower and the maximum water flow rate is 4600 gallons per hour. Read More

Best Features:

Minimizes Air Locks – It’s a top suction pump designed to minimize the air locks and clogging from rubbish at the bottom of the sump pit.

Imported Pump – It is assembled in USA with domestic and foreign components for quality and durability. It is made for 11-inches diameter and even larger sump pits.


  • Comes with Easy to install feature and highly portable and easy to handle and carry from one place to another
  • The Wayne Sump Pump has 5 years of Manufacturer’s Warranty which ensures the quality of the product


  • Not Very Durable– Most of the Wayne CDU980E Submersible fails to operate within a few uses.

Superior Pump 92330 1/3 HP Thermoplastic Sump Pump

Superior Pump 92330 1/3 HP Thermoplastic Sump Pump is of high quality and has tethered float switch which allows the pump to be used as a utility pump by eliminating the float switch. It has Split capacitor motor for continuous duty and is thermally protected. These pumps are stronger and durable, come at highly affordable price and perform the best. Read More

Best Features:

Corrosion Resistant– It’s made of thermoplastic material and stainless steel to protect the pump from corrosion, rust and decaying. The Superior Pump comes with ‘Silver and Black finish’ which makes the pump look attractive and durable.

Split Capacitor– the Superior Pump 92330 has Split capacitor motor for continuous duty and is thermally protected for any kind of rust or damage.


  • The Superior pump comes at affordable price
  • It doesn’t require any battery as the motor operates automatically



  • Float Switch Problem– The float switch doesn’t function properly at times due to which, the pump doesn’t operate automatically

Wayne VIP50 1/2 HP Thermoplastic Portable Electric Water Removal Pump

Wayne VIP50 electric water removal pump are portable in size and made of thermoplastic for durability and quality. These multi-purpose pumps are assembled in the USA with top quality material for reliability and durability. It ranges from daily use around your home to infrequent use. Usual applications include removing stagnant water off basement floors or construction sites, draining aquariums and water beds, etc. Read More

Best Features:

Horsepower – It has 1/2 horsepower, powerful in removing 2500 gallons of water per hour with a base suction which takes out water to within 8 inches of the surface.

Corrosion Resistant – It’s a glass reinforced thermoplastic for the housing, impeller and volute which prevents rust. It comes with the 3/4-inch adjustable discharge adapter which easily connects to garden hoses and an easy-access handle provides complete portability.


  • The WayneVIP50 is accumulated in the US with domestic and foreign components.
  • It has 1/2 Horse Power and is reinforced with Thermoplastic Submersible Utility Pump


  • Manual Switch Type– Wayne VIP50 has manual switch type which requires the pump to be operated manually

Zoeller M53 Mighty-Mate Submersible Sump Pump

Zoeller Submersible sump pumps are the solid pump which are very durable and rust proof. It’s a reliable pump and easy to maintain. The M53 model from Zoeller has a motor, a cast iron switch case and pump housing. It has a thermoplastic base and a wrangled plastic impeller with metal insert. Read More

Best Features:

Horsepower – the product comes with 1/3 horsepower motor for removing high amount of water within less time.

Discharge Capacity – It comes with 1.5″ discharge capacity and generous space between the feet and the actual intake to the pump. It’s a good vertical float and when installed properly doesn’t get stuck on side of basin or wires.


  • The Zoeller M53 pump comes with 1/3 Horse Power motor
  • It has 1 to1/2 inch NPT Discharge which can pass up to 1/2 inch circular solids


  • Faulty Switch– After certain use, the switch gets stuck to the pump which forces the pump to run continuously. You may require changing the switch after a certain period of time.

Choosing Your Best Sump Pump

Features Of Sump Pump

A sump pump eradicates drainage water from sump basin located in your basement or crawl space. The water may enter through the perimeter of the drainpipe, failure of waterproofing methods channelizing into the sink or due to rain or natural flooding. If the basement is under the water table, installing the pump normally takes around 30 minutes and can be done with common household tools but the main difficulty is to make the selection of the best sump pump as there are several options available in the market like the type of sump pump whether it is Pedestal, Submersible or Sump/Effluent Sump Pump. One needs to consider the current size and quality sump pump, the horsepower, diameter of your sump basin and diameter of the discharge pipe.

Sump pumps are available in different styles and sizes. To find the correct sump pump, start by analyzing your needs, measure the size and depth to ascertain an accurate fit. Features that are crucial to consider when shopping around for a submersible sump pump are:

Performance: Existing user should select the pump with the same Horse Power which matches the model they currently have. If you need a pump that runs less, you should choose a model that offers more power. Pump with higher horsepower is more effective as they flush out more gallons of water within lesser time.

Float Switch Type: 
A tethered switch floats up to an angle as water goes into the basin to trigger the pump. Tethered Switch Pumps need a sump basin size with the minimum 14” diameter.

Vertical Switch Pumps can be utilized in the basins as minute as 10” in diameter. A vertical switch shifts straight up as water gets into the basin to start the pump.

Durability: The function of the sump pump is to eradicate water from the basin, basement, etc. for which the pump remains in frequent contact with water which may result into the decayed pump, corrosion, etc. To ensure that the pump lasts for a longer duration and you should select a sump pump made with the superior materials and supported by a strong warranty.

Head Pressure: The head pressure of a sump pump illustrates the uppermost height that the pump will move water. A sump pump with a 15 feet (4.6 m) shutoff (maximum) will lift water up 15 feet (4.6 m) before it totally loses flow.

Corrosion Resistant – You should be cautious while purchasing sump pump and should only buy the pump which is made of non-corroding materials such as alloy, cast bronze, stainless steel or epoxy-coated cast iron which are durable and reliable.

Extra Protective Devices: Such as alarms and battery powered back up sump pumps can be purchased to offer you with peace of mind and added assurance against water damage in case of system failure.

Leak Detector With A Water Alarm: It’s very difficult and nearly impossible for taking too many precautions when it is about protecting your home from water. A water alarm is a tool which detects water leaks that can cause permanent damage. It identifies water on a surface with its two metal contacts. The device runs on a model 9v battery and can be put in any location where there is a risk of water seepage.

Automatic vs. Manual Operation: A manual sump pump indicates that you will turn the pump on and off when suitable. An automatic sump pump indicates that a switch is cabled to the sump pump to turn it on or off at suitable water levels. Automatic switches include pressure switch, low-level pressure switch, float switch, and a firm state water sensor called field-effect.

Battery Backup Systems: In order to protect your home from massive flood damage you should definitely consider buying a sump pump. But it is equally important that you add an emergency battery back up to the sump pump systems.

A backup system ensures extra peace of mind, preventing your home against power fluctuation or outage, failure of the sump pump and heavy rains that can over flood your sump pump system.

Though it totally depends upon your discreet choice whether you choose submersible or pedestal sump pump, the submersible sump pump has several features which make it a better choice. It comes with a watertight motor completely sealed and submerged in oil which makes it fully functional under water. It is located at the base of a sump basin and fit below water level. Although it is little costlier than the pedestal pump, it has considerable benefits:

  • Quieter than the pedestal
  • Less maintenance required
  • Submerged in water
  • Can easily handle larger quantities of water
  • Less dangerous to children as it’s submerged in water

Types Of Sump Pumps

Even for the new buyer, the following criteria should be the decisive points for choosing the good quality sump pump.

Following Are The Types of Sump Pumps

There are usually two types of sump pumps – submersible and pedestal sump pump. IN case of pedestal pump the motor is mounted above the sump. Submersible Pump-  and Pedestal pumps are both very regular with the common performance but environment-friendly people should opt for the submersible pumps as they are quieter, highly durable, easier to manage and handle and totally hidden within the sump basin.

Effluent pumps are specifically designed to manage solids up to ½” in diameter. These pumps are recommended for houses with sump basins that normally collect dirt and remains. If you want this type of pump, you should be sure to select the product that is clearly manifested as a “sump/effluent pump”.

Types Of Sump Pumps

Pedestal Sump Pump

These pumps stand upright, with the motor a few feet above so that it doesn’t get wet. It has a float-activated switch that automatically turns the pump on when the water achieves a certain level. Ideal for basements which need frequent water drainage, they usually are the least expensive but are noisier than the submersibles.

Submersible Sump Pump 

These types of electrical pumps are put in the ground and are manufactured to work underwater. They have the same float-activated switch which is more expensive than the pedestal pumps but are quieter and have a longer life and elasticity because their sealed, oil-cooled motors are protected from moisture and dust.

Plastic vs. Cast Iron Pumps

Cast iron pumps are a better choice as they are long lasting and durable. Irrespective of the type, each sump pump should have a check valve which prevents water from flowing back into the sump when the pump turns off. It may cause the pump to be operated more frequently than necessary and shorten the life of the pump.

Water Powered Sump Pump

These pumps run off the water pressure from your home plumbing system and have the float-activated switch. They handle water at a comparable rate to the electric types, but require no electricity to operate.

Floor Sucker Pumps

These pumps are used mainly in basements, cellars or edge spaces which do not have an actual sump pit. It is called a floor sucker pump as it eliminates water precisely down to within a 1/8″ of the floor. They are available in several flow rates operated either manually or automatically.

Automatic Switch Sump Pump

This is the best choice as it will start the sump pump if flooding occurs in your absence. The manual switch requires someone to turn on the switch for starting the sump pump.


Sump pumps are manufactured by different brands with a range of models. Some brands offer free installation while others install it at a small charge. However, it is suggested that a submersible pump may be installed by a trained mechanic as improper installation can lead to system break down and thus may not guarantee protection against flooding. The best sump pump should have some features like higher horsepower to flush away more gallons of water per hour. Automatic sump pump gives you more peace of mind as it takes care of the water logging in your absence too. To clean your home as you need vacuum cleaners, good pressure washers & other equipment, a sump pump is a priority for the areas prone to flooding. It is important that you purchase the best quality sump pump for durability and prevention from rust and corrosion. The above-mentioned sump pump reviews are in line with some of the best sump pumps being sold in the market. We recommend you to always buy the right product from like you buy for your health & for kitchen use